A recent sugar trade deal between the US and Mexico may be the prelude to upcoming North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) negotiations. Mexico agreed to reduce refined sugar exports to the United States from 53 percent of its total sugar exports to 30 percent. In turn, the country’s exporters will see a minimum price increase of 2 cents per pound for refined sugar imports to the United States.
Although Mexico’s compromise averted a trade meltdown, the agreement is unlikely to be a long-term fix. Trade negotiators may be right back at the table if Mexico exploits a loophole to meet excess demand from the US next year.
Amid trade tensions, both countries also contend with lackluster domestic demand for refined sweeteners. The Mexican government has lifted the amount of ethanol that can be blended with gasoline from 5.8 percent to 10 percent. In contrast, the US has opted to preserve the status quo by protecting its domestic sugar and corn syrup processing industries.
Consumers pay higher prices as the subsidies fly. With competing domestic policies and a likely NAFTA showdown, both countries are pondering whether the future is so sweet after all.
The Mexican and US landscapes for sugar cultivation differ greatly. In one of the country’s primary agricultural activities, 150,000 Mexican sugarcane growers directly or indirectly employ roughly 2 million people. Sugarcane plots in Mexico average roughly four hectares (10 acres) in size. In stark contrast, the United States has just over 600 sugarcane growers cultivating on average plot of 500 hectares (1,236 acres). The US also has 4,000 sugar beet farms with an average size measuring 130 hectares (320 acres).
Both countries’ sugar policies march to similar protectionist beats. The US has collected protective tariffs on foreign sugar imports since the dawn of the Republic. The US has liberalized its trade relationship with Mexico following NAFTA. Despite WTO obligations, the country tightly controls supply from other countries by setting trade restricted quotas—or the amount of imports qualifying for low or zero duties.
The USDA allocates a share of the estimated US sugar market to domestic producers. In theory, this should prevent market oversupply. US sugar growers also receive loans that guarantee a minimum producer price regardless of actual market conditions. These measures work to ensure that US raw and refined sugar prices are generally higher than the world reference price, much to the detriment of confectionary companies. While the US generously protects its sugar industry, neglected food and beverage companies have moved operations elsewhere in search of cheaper sweeteners.
Within Mexico, current sugar subsidies come largely in the form of direct price support. The Decretos cañeros, a government act that was intended to attract foreign investment to the sector, established set reference prices for sugarcane, which the government revises periodically to reflect market conditions. However, domestic control over the industry has fluctuated since the 1970s when the government nationalized the country’s sugar mills. More recently, the Mexican government has increasingly divested its direct involvement in the industry, which is comprised of less than 60 mills.
Over 80 percent of Mexico’s sugar output comes from nine states spread across its Gulf and Pacific coastal regions. In the United States, production of sugar is split roughly 55/45 between beet and cane cultivation. Sugar beets are grown in 14 states, but more than 50 percent of annual production comes from just Minnesota and North Dakota. Likewise, sugarcane production is heavily concentrated in Florida and Louisiana, which account for well over 90 percent of US production.
With the exception of the 2012/13 season, Mexico’s raw sugar output has remained around 6 million metric tons (tonnes) even after the country received unfettered access to the US market in January 2008. Sugarcane yields still remain below global standards in many parts of Mexico. In fact, Mexico’s growers harvested roughly 69 tons of sugarcane per hectare (t/ha) in 2016 compared to 78.5 t/ha for US growers and nearly 75 t/ha for Brazilian producers. However, the country has the potential to produce more higher-quality sugarcane, particularly in the Jalisco, Morelos, Puebla, and Chiapas regions.
On the other hand, US sugar production has steadily climbed between 2008 to 2017 in response to a 15 percent increase in domestic demand. While Mexico’s total demand for sugar has held steady over the same time period, the country’s tax on sugary drinks is clearly impacting consumption. Soda sales were down 5.5 percent in 2014 and 9.7 percent in 2015, respectively.
Prior to 2008, Mexico’s imports of high fructose corn syrup (HFCS) from the United States and US exports of sugar to Mexico were limited and fluctuated significantly. The removal of all quota and tariff restrictions immediately transformed cross-border trade flows. Mexican sugar not only became a competitive substitute to US-cultivated sugar, but also took share from HFCS in the US. HFCS as a percentage of US sweetener supply averaged 39 percent between 2012 and 2014, down from 44 percent in between 2004 and 2006. Mexican sugar became relatively more cost-efficient as rising corn use in ethanol production inflated corn prices. At the same time, public debate over the health impact of HFCS resulted in food and beverage manufacturers replacing HFCS with sugar.
Since the United States consumes most, if not all, of its annual sugar production, rising domestic demand of sugar called for more imports. Mexican exports of sugar to the United States roughly doubled between 2008 and 2014. The new trade regime worked so handsomely in Mexico’s favor that enterprising middlemen would import raw sugar from other global markets and re-export it to the US.
US corn syrup producers also benefited greatly from NAFTA. Many Mexican bottling companies found US corn syrup to be cheaper and more reliable than domestic sources. Exports of HFCS to Mexico quickly picked up steam. HFCS increased from 9 percent of Mexican sweetener use between 2005 and 2007 to roughly 25 percent between 2012 and 2014.
The harmonious balance of rising sweetener trade between Mexico and US ended in 2013. A jump in sugarcane area in Mexico coincided with a tighter spread between US and global sugar prices. As a result, Mexico’s exporters had a greater incentive to export to the US. Total exports of sugar products from Mexico to the US doubled in 2013 from the prior year. Of course, US sugar refineries have no issues with Mexico sending them cheap raw sugar. In fact, the industry has been pushing the US government to expand the quota for raw sugar imports for years. However, growing refined sugar imports to the US caught the attention of the industry.
In an interesting twist, the simultaneous rise in raw and refined sugar imports from Mexico united growers and refiners. The US sugar industry banded together to press for a US International Trade Commission (USITC) ruling against Mexico. Both countries threatened retaliatory measures during the review process.
At the end of the day, both countries agreed to bury the hatchet, as there was too much on the line. They signed a suspension agreement establishing a limit on Mexican sugar exports to the United States. Mexico also agreed to limit refined sugar exports to the US at 53 percent of its total exports. In return, the US set a minimum import price for Mexican refined and raw sugar of 26 and 22.5 cents per pound, respectively. Still, bad blood between the trade partners lingered.
Mexico increased exports to the US of partially-refined sugar, which is technically raw under trade specifications, despite the 2014 agreement. With the country sending less raw cane sugar to the US, US domestic refiners became increasingly dependent on US production and higher-cost imports from other countries via the tariff-rate-quota system.
At the same time, Mexico’s sugar mills and independent players built more “melt house” capacity in the US. Melt houses process partially-refined sugar into liquefied sugar rather than crush and process raw sugar. Liquefied sugar has become increasingly popular among food manufacturers looking for a cheaper sweetener source or a substitute to corn syrup. Under the 2014 ceasefire, Mexico’s exporters were able to export sugar that was technically raw—up to a polarity level of 99.5 percent—but could be easily processed into refined sugar by independent refiners. Indeed, US refiners persuaded the US Department of Commerce to resume investigations into Mexico’s exploitation of this loophole in January 2015. The USITC ruled again in favor of the US sugar industry.
Tensions between the countries ran high ahead of the June 5, 2017 deadline, but disaster was, once again, averted. Mexico agreed to lower the share of its refined sugar imports to the US from 47 percent to 30 percent in return for a roughly 2 cents per pound increase in minimum import prices for refined sugar. Mexico also gained the title of supplier of “first refusal”, which allows the country to supply any extra U.S. sugar demand.
US sugar refineries also won a few key concessions. All raw Mexican sugar will have to be shipped via dry bulk shipping vessels to US ports of destination. The thought is that the availability of Mexican raw sugar will improve for domestic refineries, as most of their legacy operations are located near major port hubs. The polarity limits for raw sugar were also reduced from 99.5 percent to 99.2 percent, which, in theory, should benefit sugar cane refiners at the expense of domestic melt houses.
Still, the US sugar industry has come out against the “grand compromise.” Mexico will be allowed to meet extra US sugar demand under the old polarity definition for raw sugar, which provides a technical loophole. In effect, the industry believes Mexico may end up exporting just as much partially-refined sugar into the US if the USDA calls for extra demand.
While this latest deal will allow NAFTA negotiations to start under calmer circumstances, the root cause of the trade scuffle remains. The United States keeps protecting the margins of sweetener processors at the expense of US consumers and food companies. Despite little evidence of dumping by Mexican exporters, the Mexican government seems most concerned about securing higher import prices and other concessions for Mexico’s growers. The country’s bottling industry isn’t protesting too much over this favoritism. Since Mexico’s bottlers face a domestic deficit, they are happy for the source of tariff-free corn syrup.
Global confectionary companies have largely moved production offshore. They are unlikely to raise a vocal protest during future trade talks unless they are threatened by higher US tariffs. As such, we see politically-connected growers and processors continuing to control US sugar policy. However, US corn processors’ win is pyrrhic at best, with Mexican soda consumption declining and domestic HFCS demand stalled.
Meanwhile, Mexico is trying to even up the score for processors by increasing support for ethanol. Given that the country’s sugar productivity has lagged behind global peers, it is worth asking whether Mexico’s subsidies for cane growers are part of the problem.
All this subsidization is clearly leading to less-than-efficient industries on both sides of the border. Yet politics sometimes trumps logic.
Receive our research in your inbox
Thank you for subscribing to our newsletter!
What Information Do We Collect?
The information we gather enables us to personalize, improve and continue to operate the Services. We collect the following types of information from our users.
IP Address Information and Other Information Collected Automatically:
· We automatically receive and record information from your web browser when you interact with the Services, including your IP address and cookie information. This information is used for fighting spam/malware and also to facilitate collection of data concerning your interaction with the Services (e.g., what links you have clicked on).
· Generally, the Services automatically collect usage information, such as the number and frequency of visitors to the Site. We may use this data in aggregate form, that is, as a statistical measure, but not in a manner that would identify you personally. This type of aggregate data enables us and third parties authorized by us to figure out how often individuals use parts of the Services so that we can analyze and improve them.
Information Collected Using Cookies:
· Most browsers have an option for turning off the cookie feature, which will prevent your browser from accepting new cookies, as well as (depending on the sophistication of your browser software) allowing you to decide on acceptance of each new cookie in a variety of ways.
We collect statistical information about how users collectively use the Services (“Aggregate Information”). Some of this information may be derived from Personal Information. This statistical information is not Personal Information and cannot be tied back to you or your web browser.
How, and With Whom, Is My Information Shared?
IP Address Information:
Information You Elect to Share:
We share Aggregate Information with our partners, service providers and other persons with whom we conduct business. We share this type of statistical data so that our partners can understand how and how often people use our Services and their services or websites, which facilitates improving both their services and how our Services interface with them. In addition, these third parties may share with us non-private, aggregated or otherwise non Personal Information about you that they have independently developed or acquired.
Information Shared with Our Agents:
We employ and contract with people and other entities that perform certain tasks on our behalf and who are under our control (our “Agents”). We may need to share Personal Information with our Agents in order to provide products or services to you. Unless we tell you differently, our Agents do not have any right to use Personal Information or other information we share with them beyond what is necessary to assist us. You hereby consent to our sharing of Personal Information with our Agents.
Information Disclosed Pursuant to Business Transfers:
In some cases, we may choose to buy or sell assets. In these types of transactions, user information is typically one of the transferred business assets. Moreover, if we, or substantially all of our assets, were acquired, or if we go out of business or enter bankruptcy, user information would be one of the assets that is transferred or acquired by a third party. You acknowledge that such transfers may occur, and that any acquirer of us or our assets may continue to use your Personal Information as set forth in this policy.
Information Disclosed for Our Protection and the Protection of Others:
Information We Share With Your Consent:
Except as set forth above, you will be notified when your Personal Information may be shared with third parties, and will be able to prevent the sharing of this information.
Is Information About Me Secure?
We store all of our information, including your IP address information, using industry-standard techniques. We do not guarantee or warrant that such techniques will prevent unauthorized access to information about you that we store, Personal Information or otherwise.
What Information of Mine Can I Access?
You can access and delete cookies through your web browser settings.
California Privacy Rights: Under California Civil Code sections 1798.83-1798.84, California residents are entitled to ask us for a notice identifying the categories of personal customer information which we share with our affiliates and/or third parties for marketing purposes, and providing contact information for such affiliates and/or third parties. If you are a California resident and would like a copy of this notice, please submit a written request to the following address: 12 E 49th Street, 11th Floor, New York, NY 10017
What If I Have Questions or Concerns?
If you have any questions or concerns regarding privacy using the Services, please send us a detailed message to firstname.lastname@example.org. We will make every effort to resolve your concerns.
Effective Date: March 11, 2014
b. You shall not (directly or indirectly):i. take any action that imposes or may impose (as determined by us in our sole discretion) an unreasonable or disproportionately large load on our (or our third party providers’) infrastructure;ii. interfere or attempt to interfere with the proper working of the Services or any activities conducted on the Services;iii. bypass, circumvent or attempt to bypass or circumvent any measures we may use to prevent or restrict access to the Services (or other accounts, computer systems or networks connected to the Services);iv. use manual or automated software, devices, or other processes to “crawl” or “spider” any page of the Site;
v. harvest or scrape any Content from the Services;
vi. otherwise take any action in violation of our guidelines and policies;vii. decipher, decompile, disassemble, reverse engineer or otherwise attempt to derive any source code or underlying ideas or algorithms of any part of the Services (including without limitation any application), except to the limited extent applicable laws specifically prohibit such restriction;viii. modify, translate, or otherwise create derivative works of any part of the Services; orix. copy, rent, lease, distribute, or otherwise transfer any of the rights that you receive hereunder.c. We also reserve the right to access, read, preserve, and disclose any information as we reasonably believe is necessary to:i. satisfy any applicable law, regulation, legal process or governmental request;ii. enforce these Terms of Service, including investigation of potential violations hereof;
iii. detect, prevent, or otherwise address fraud, security or technical issues;
iv. respond to user support requests; or
v. protect the rights, property or safety of us, our users and the public.4. Third Party Services. The Services may permit you to link to other websites, services or resources on the Internet, and other websites, services or resources may contain links to the Services. When you access third party resources on the Internet, you do so at your own risk. These other resources are not under our control, and you acknowledge that we are not responsible or liable for the content, functions, accuracy, legality, appropriateness or any other aspect of such websites or resources. The inclusion of any such link does not imply our endorsement or any association between us and their operators. You further acknowledge and agree that we shall not be responsible or liable, directly or indirectly, for any damage or loss caused or alleged to be caused by or in connection with the use of or reliance on any such content, goods or services available on or through any such website or resource.5. Termination. We may terminate your access to all or any part of the Services at any time, with or without cause, with or without notice, effective immediately. All provisions of these Terms of Service which by their nature should survive termination shall survive termination, including, without limitation, ownership provisions, warranty disclaimers, indemnity and limitations of liability.6. Warranty Disclaimer.a. You release us from all liability for you having acquired or not acquired Content through the Services. We make no representations concerning any Content contained in or accessed through the Services, and we will not be responsible or liable for the accuracy, copyright compliance, or legality of material or Content contained in or accessed through the Services.b. THE SERVICES AND CONTENT ARE PROVIDED “AS IS”, “AS AVAILABLE” AND WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF TITLE, NON-INFRINGEMENT, MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, AND ANY WARRANTIES IMPLIED BY ANY COURSE OF PERFORMANCE OR USAGE OF TRADE, ALL OF WHICH ARE EXPRESSLY DISCLAIMED. WE, AND OUR DIRECTORS, EMPLOYEES, AGENTS, SUPPLIERS, PARTNERS AND CONTENT PROVIDERS DO NOT WARRANT THAT: (I) THE SERVICES WILL BE SECURE OR AVAILABLE AT ANY PARTICULAR TIME OR LOCATION; (II) ANY DEFECTS OR ERRORS WILL BE CORRECTED; (III) ANY CONTENT AVAILABLE AT OR THROUGH THE SERVICES IS FREE OF VIRUSES OR OTHER HARMFUL COMPONENTS; OR (IV) THE RESULTS OF USING THE SERVICES WILL MEET YOUR REQUIREMENTS.7. Limitation of Liability. IN NO EVENT SHALL WE, NOR OUR DIRECTORS, EMPLOYEES, AGENTS, PARTNERS, SUPPLIERS OR CONTENT PROVIDERS, BE LIABLE UNDER CONTRACT, TORT, STRICT LIABILITY, NEGLIGENCE OR ANY OTHER LEGAL OR EQUITABLE THEORY WITH RESPECT TO THE SERVICES FOR ANY (I) LOST PROFITS, DATA LOSS, COST OF PROCUREMENT OF SUBSTITUTE GOODS OR SERVICES, OR SPECIAL, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, PUNITIVE, COMPENSATORY OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES OF ANY KIND WHATSOEVER, SUBSTITUTE GOODS OR SERVICES (HOWEVER ARISING), (II) BUGS, VIRUSES, TROJAN HORSES, OR THE LIKE (REGARDLESS OF THE SOURCE OF ORIGINATION), OR (III) DIRECT DAMAGES IN EXCESS OF $50.00.8. Governing Law and Jurisdiction. These Terms of Service shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the State of New York, including its conflicts of law rules, and the United States of America. You agree that any dispute arising from or relating to the subject matter of these Terms of Service shall be governed by the exclusive jurisdiction and venue of the state and Federal courts of New York County, New York.9. Miscellaneous.a. Modification. We reserve the right, in our sole discretion, to modify or replace any of these Terms of Service, or change, suspend, or discontinue the Services at any time. Your continued use of the Services following notification of any changes to these Terms of Service constitutes acceptance of those changes.b. Entire Agreement and Severability. These Terms of Service are the entire agreement between you and us with respect to the Services, including use of the Site, and supersede all prior or contemporaneous communications and proposals (whether oral, written or electronic) between you and us with respect to the Services. If any provision of these Terms of Service is found to be unenforceable or invalid, that provision will be limited or eliminated to the minimum extent necessary so that these Terms of Service will otherwise remain in full force and effect and enforceable. The failure of either party to exercise in any respect any right provided for herein shall not be deemed a waiver of any further rights hereunderc. Force Majeure. We shall not be liable for any failure to perform our obligations hereunder where such failure results from any cause beyond our reasonable control, including, without limitation, mechanical, electronic or communications failure or degradation.d. Assignment. These Terms of Service are personal to you, and are not assignable, transferable or sublicensable by you except with our prior written consent. We may assign, transfer or delegate any of our rights and obligations hereunder without consent.e. Agency. No agency, partnership, joint venture, or employment relationship is created as a result of these Terms of Service and neither party has any authority of any kind to bind the other in any respect.f. Notices. Unless otherwise specified in these Term of Service, all notices under these Terms of Service will be in writing and will be deemed to have been duly given when received, if personally delivered or sent by certified or registered mail, return receipt requested; when receipt is electronically confirmed, if transmitted by facsimile or e-mail; or the day after it is sent, if sent for next day delivery by recognized overnight delivery service. Electronic notices should be sent to email@example.com. No Waiver. Our failure to enforce any part of these Terms of Service shall not constitute a waiver of our right to later enforce that or any other part of these Terms of Service. Waiver of compliance in any particular instance does not mean that we will waive compliance in the future. In order for any waiver of compliance with these Terms of Service to be binding, we must provide you with written notice of such waiver through one of our authorized representatives.h. Headings. The section and paragraph headings in these Terms of Service are for convenience only and shall not affect their interpretation.Contact. You may contact us at the following address: 12 E 49th Street, 11th Floor, New York, NY 10017.